A line (and an e-book) in the sand?

Jen book

Ok, so I know that everything is moving online, and using our BlackBerry/iPhone/iPad/laptop is what keeps us going everyday as we constantly crave that unlimited, quick, delicious information. But I have to draw a line somewhere, and that line is with e-books.

Call me old fashioned, but I love books. I love the look of books, the feel of them, the smell of new pages, I even love sticking in my little silver bookmark to show people how far I've got in the book (feeling particularly satisfied when it's a really big book). It's also the thrill of adding a new "trophy" to my bookshelf. To me, the thought of replacing books with e-books is almost sacrilegious.

I feel that when you take the time out to read a good book, the last thing you want to do is look at yet another handheld device when settling down to read your romantic novel. It just doesn't make sense to me. Using the Kindle as an example, I try and think of what kind of people would buy one, and the first two types that come to mind are the typical business man/woman and the 'cash rich, time poor' who get it out to read on a plane or train journey to pass time. As a passionate book lover, I'm struggling to see how it could replace the original print version.

When I come across stories about e-books either in the paper or online, I take the time to read them, as well as the comments of that story to try and grasp what people think about them. To my surprise, they are predominantly positive - people seem to love their Kindle. People talk about the convenience, the space saving, the unlimited access to books, the fact there you no longer have to queue in book stores or have to order them in when what you want is out of stock. Ok, maybe there is a point there, but when they mention convenience, here's what I think of: I love reading a good book whilst lying on the beach (If I was using a Kindle, talk about getting sand in unwanted places!) or whilst soaking in the bath (hmm...are they water proof?). That doesn't sound too convenient to me.  Clearly, it's only the old fashioned book girl that still won't let go of her paperbacks for the reasons I've mentioned above.

We still need a lot of convincing. I will never say never, and maybe one day we will be persuaded to trade but, for now, I will keep on adding countless books to my precious collection.

Jen


Bookmark and Share
 /

7 comments for “A line (and an e-book) in the sand?”

  1. Gravatar of lisalisa
    Posted 16 August 2010 at 14:30:54

    i totally agree, traditional books are the way forward. a very good piece of writing. look forward to her next blog.

  2. Gravatar of Lisa HLisa H
    Posted 17 August 2010 at 10:36:26

    I am firmly on your side with this. Snapping a book shut when it get's a bit too scary (as my current read is) is part of the theatre involved - keep it real

  3. Gravatar of Kathryn CotsworthKathryn Cotsworth
    Posted 18 August 2010 at 16:05:55

    Completely agree Jen, its just not the same!

    Especially having just spent a very self-indulgent Saturday snuggled up on my sofa reading a book while it rained outside. It just wouldn't have been the same with an e-reader.

  4. Gravatar of Dan PurvisDan Purvis
    Posted 19 August 2010 at 11:10:59

    Completely agree...on my last holiday I saw a few people with e-books and thought "ridiculous". Nothing better than finishing a good book and putting it worn and well-read on the bookshelf. Though didn't people say the same about downloading music instead of buying CDs?

  5. Gravatar of Rebecca TaylorRebecca Taylor
    Posted 24 August 2010 at 13:45:17

    I totally agree Jen - one of the things I love most about reading is that there is no screen involved, and after 12hrs in front of a laptop at work another screen is the last thing I need! Dan has a good point about the CDs, but I still prefer buying them as well!

  6. Posted 02 September 2010 at 12:17:59

    I would have been right with you on most points until this week when I finally got my hands on a Kindle. They seem pretty good to me, and not a silly price point either at £109 for the basic model. Also, on the one I saw the "screen" looked so much like paper I was amazed, so it doesn't feel quite as much like "just another screen" as I thought it would have. I may be spending some of my bonus on one.
    Another plus is there is no cover to give away the fact I'm reading Twilight yet again ;-)

  7. Posted 09 September 2010 at 12:17:04

    Couldn't agree more Jen! I love books and the escape from a screen is very welcome! Reading a book juts feels so nostalgic and nice!

    I get especially narked at the new Kindle advert showing two people on a beach reading their ebooks. This seems the most stupid situation for a £100 piece of equipment! Sand and sea? I'd be terrified of breaking it.

    Plus, I love rediscovering a book I read on holiday years later when it's slightly worn and you can smell the beach on it. Brings back even more memories!

Post a comment